Teaching Portraiture Without Intimidating Beginners
Quick answer: Start with proportion, not likeness. Teach the head as a shape with measured landmarks, drill features separately for a week, then combine. Beginners quit portraits because they compare their drawing to a real face and lose. Give them a target they can check against a ruler and the quitting mostly stops.
Why do beginners give up on faces so fast?
Because every viewer is an expert on faces. A student who draws a mediocre tree gets a shrug; a student who draws a mediocre face gets told it looks wrong, and they can see it themselves. The gap between intention and result is more visible in portraiture than in any other subject.
The way out is to change what counts as success for the first two weeks. Success is not likeness. Success is: eyes on the halfway line, five eye-widths across, bottom of the nose halfway between brow and chin, mouth one third down from nose to chin, ears from brow line to nose line. Those are measurable. A student can hold a ruler against their own drawing and know whether they got it, without an opinion entering the room.
What is the sequence that actually works?
Week 1, proportion. Three sessions of the same exercise: an oval, a vertical center line, a horizontal eye line, then the four remaining landmarks measured, no features drawn. Fifteen minutes each. By the third time most students place the eye line correctly without being told, which is the single biggest correction beginners need, since almost everyone puts eyes too high.
Week 2, features in isolation. One period each on eyes, nose, mouth. Draw from a printed reference at four times life size. Large is easier. An eye drawn two inches wide teaches more than an eye drawn a quarter inch wide, and the enlargement removes the likeness problem entirely.
Week 3, combine. Self-portrait from a mirror or a phone photo, using the proportion scaffold from week one and the feature drills from week two. Two periods for the drawing, one for value.
Common failure: students abandon the scaffold as soon as they start features, then wonder why the face collapses. Have them redraw the landmark lines in a colored pencil that stays visible under the graphite.
The ready-made version of this lesson
- Mask Making Activities: Face Proportions, Mask Design & Masks in Culture (Grades 5-8) — $24.99, instant download
- Frida Kahlo: Self-Portrait and Symbolism — $24.99, instant download
- Rembrandt: Portrait and Chiaroscuro — $24.99, instant download
More in Art. Every download has a 30-day money-back guarantee.
What do you do about the student who refuses to draw a face?
Offer a side entrance. Portraiture is about identity, and there are ways in that do not require a nose.
A symbolic self-portrait fills the head shape with objects, patterns and text instead of features. A profile silhouette traced from a shadow on the wall, then filled with collage, is a real portrait tradition and takes the drawing pressure off. A portrait of hands, or of the objects on someone's desk, tells you as much about a person as their face does. A mask design lets a student build a face without owning it.
These are not consolation prizes. Say so. If you frame them as the easy option, the students who need them will refuse them too.
How do you differentiate a portrait unit?
Approaching: pre-printed proportion grid on the drawing paper. Feature drills traced first, then drawn freehand next to the trace. Self-portrait from a photo rather than a mirror, since a photo holds still. Accept a completed profile silhouette as the final piece.
On level: the three-week sequence as written, from a mirror, with a value study in three tones.
Above level: a three-quarter view, which breaks the symmetry rules and forces real observation. Or a portrait with a deliberate light source from below or behind, which is where chiaroscuro stops being a vocabulary word.
What materials and timings should you plan for?
Per student for the whole unit: six sheets of 9x12 drawing paper, an HB and a 4B pencil, a kneaded eraser, and a small mirror. Hand mirrors run about a dollar each in bulk, and a class set lasts years if you store them in a shoebox with cardboard dividers.
Total time: nine to eleven 50-minute periods. Do not compress it to five. The proportion week feels slow and is the reason the rest works.
Frequently asked questions
Should students draw from photos or from life?
Photos for the first attempt, life afterward. A photo is already flattened, which removes one problem while they solve the others.
How do I handle students drawing each other?
Set the rule before you pair anyone: the drawing is about proportion practice, and nobody comments on anyone else's likeness. Give students the option to opt out and work from a photo.
What about drawing a range of faces?
Use reference photos of many different people from the start. A unit taught entirely from one type of face teaches students that other faces are deviations, which is both bad art teaching and worse than that.
Is the Loomis method too advanced for middle school?
Mostly yes. The ball-and-plane construction helps students who already draw confidently, but for beginners it adds steps between them and a finished face.
Comments
No comments yet — be the first to share your thoughts!
Leave a comment
Comments are reviewed before being published.
Thanks for your comment!
Your comment is being reviewed and will appear here shortly.