Exclusive or Basic? How to Decide Before December 31, 2026

If you are a Premium Seller on TPT, you have until December 31, 2026 to decide whether to opt in to Exclusive Seller. According to TPT, if you do nothing, your account becomes a Basic account on January 1, 2027. Either way you end up on one of two tiers, so the real choice is between Exclusive and Basic.

There is no answer that suits everyone. A seller who has only ever sold on TPT faces a different choice from one who also runs a shop on her own website. Below are the questions we think are worth answering, in the order that tends to settle things fastest. None of this is legal or financial advice, and TeachLessons has its own seller program, so read our view with that in mind.

Question 1: Do you sell, or want to sell, anywhere else?

Start here, because it can decide the matter on its own. According to TPT, Exclusive Sellers commit to selling TPT-eligible resources exclusively on TPT. If most of your income comes from another place, such as your own website or another marketplace, and those resources would count as eligible, Exclusive may not fit.

If you have never sold anywhere else and have no plans to, the exclusivity condition costs you nothing you were using. In that case the decision is mostly about money and tools, which is where the next questions come in.

Be careful with the word eligible. TPT defines it, and we won't. Read TPT's terms and, if anything is unclear, bring it to TPT's Town Hall on October 8, 2026. Our list of questions to check in TPT's exclusivity terms can help.

Question 2: What does the per-sale gap look like at your prices?

On every price in TPT's structure, Exclusive pays more per sale than Basic. How much more depends on what you charge. Here are the figures from TPT's published rates, assuming one resource per order:

Notice how the gap grows with price. A seller whose catalog is mostly $3 worksheets sees a difference of under a dollar per sale. A seller with $20 units sees almost five dollars. Before you go further, write down your three or four most common price points and the number of sales at each from last year. You will use those figures in the next two questions, and they are worth more than any general rule.

Question 3: Will your TPT sales cover the $59.95?

Exclusive costs $59.95 a year. Basic, as TPT describes it, has a one-time $29 fee. For Exclusive to come out ahead of Basic on TPT sales alone, the extra you earn per sale has to add up to more than the annual fee.

At $10, the extra is $2.55 per sale, so you need about 24 sales in a year. At $5, it takes about 43 sales. If you sell more than that, Exclusive pays more on TPT. Our break-even article has the full table and shows the math.

If you are well past break-even and TPT is your only channel, Exclusive will often be the simpler choice. Most Premium Sellers will clear that bar easily, so this question mostly matters for smaller stores.

Question 4: How much would you earn outside TPT?

This is the hardest question, because it involves sales that haven't happened yet. If you choose Basic, you keep the freedom to list the same resources elsewhere. The question is whether those other sales would make up for the lower Basic rate on TPT.

Do it honestly. Look at what your other channels earned in the last year, if you have any. If you have none, don't assume a number you can't support. A new channel is a possibility, not a guarantee.

If you want to test that path, TeachLessons pays 70% of the price after a flat 3% payment cost, which comes to $6.79 on a $10 sale or $13.58 on a $20 sale. There is no fee to join and no exclusivity. You can see every price point in the payout calculator. We can't promise sales volume, so only count what you are confident about.

Question 5: Do you want TPT's Exclusive tools?

TPT says Exclusive Sellers get Search Analytics, a Keyword Finder, promotional tools and possible inclusion in TPT-funded campaigns. If you already spend time on keyword research and promotions inside TPT, these may be worth real money to you. If you rarely use such tools, give them less weight.

Once you have answers to all five questions, write down your choice and the reason. If you opt in, honor the commitment for the resources it covers. If you choose Basic and want a second channel, you can submit your resources to TeachLessons at any time. Our overview of the 2027 changes is a good refresher if you need one.

TeachLessons is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Teachers Pay Teachers. TPT figures here are as TPT published them on its seller fee page, current as of October 2026.

Questions sellers ask

More for teacher-sellers

TeachLessons is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Teachers Pay Teachers (TPT). "TPT" and "Teachers Pay Teachers" are trademarks of their owner and are used here only to refer to that platform. TPT figures are as TPT published them in October 2026; check TPT's seller fee page for current terms. General information, not legal, tax or financial advice.