Grades 7–11 · Social Studies
How do you teach the Harlem Renaissance and the New Deal as evidence labs?
Short answer: Treat each period as a question students answer with sources. For the Harlem Renaissance, students build a network diagram of magazines, clubs and places, then decide which links the sources actually support. For the New Deal, they compare modeled projects against a town's needs and state what each project could not achieve on its own.
- Grades7–10 Harlem Renaissance, 8–11 New Deal
- SourcesClassroom source cards and modeled project cases
- SkillsNetwork claims, fit-and-limits analysis
- Per unit4 double lessons, 5 worksheets, 5 answer keys, 16 slides
The 1920s and 1930s are often taught as a contrast: a decade of creativity followed by a decade of crisis and response. That framing is useful, but students rarely get to see how historians build claims about either period. They read summaries and remember names without practicing the reasoning behind them.
Two TeachLessons social studies units turn these decades into evidence labs. Both use classroom source cards and modeled cases rather than long readings, and both ask students to separate what a source shows from what it only suggests. The Harlem Renaissance unit points students to the Library of Congress collection for original items.
Units for this topic
The Harlem Renaissance Source Lab
The Harlem Renaissance Source Lab builds evidence-labeled network claims about writers, clubs and places.
New Deal Programs Evidence Lab
New Deal Programs Evidence Lab compares modeled projects for fit and limits.
Great Migration Map and Oral History Lab
Great Migration Map and Oral History Lab connects the movement north to both decades.
Poetry Performance Studio
Poetry Performance Studio adds a performance task that pairs with the 1920s lab.
Writing Effective Counterclaims
Writing Effective Counterclaims supports the written recommendation in the New Deal lab.
Ellis Island Manifest Investigation
Ellis Island Manifest Investigation builds the record-reading habits these labs depend on.
The Harlem Renaissance as a network
The Harlem Renaissance Source Lab gives source cards in paraphrased categories: a literary magazine that publishes emerging writers, a club that programs performances and a neighborhood map that locates both near other institutions. Students build a network diagram and explain what geographic closeness can and cannot establish.
The cases test each link. A magazine card names a poet, and a club card names a singer, both in Harlem. What might connect them? Not much yet. When a later event program lists both, the link becomes stronger. A photograph of a crowded reading room supports a claim about use, but leaves the readers unknown. The learning check asks which claim is more defensible after a single photo of two performers: that they met there, or that they toured together for years.
- Draw a node for each person, publication and place
- Label every link with its evidence
- Mark links that rest only on closeness
- Strengthen or drop links as new sources arrive
The New Deal: fit and limits
New Deal Programs Evidence Lab gives two case cards. Project A repairs a public building and offers 30 temporary jobs. Project B is a conservation project with 20 field crews. A fictional town needs a safer school roof and has reported 45 unemployed residents. Students compare purposes, recommend one option and state one outcome it cannot secure on its own.
The cases shift the goal to show how recommendations depend on priorities. If the council values immediate building safety, one project fits better. If it values short-term employment alone, the comparison changes. The learning check asks what students can infer when 45 people apply for 30 positions: at least 15 applicants will not get a job if all are filled once. A transfer case asks what evidence would be needed before claiming one local example proves nationwide success.
Connecting the two decades
The Great Migration links both periods. Great Migration Map and Oral History Lab shows movement from southern states to northern cities, which is part of the background to Harlem's growth as a cultural center in the 1920s. Teaching the three units in order gives students a continuous thread through the period, built on the same evidence habits.
A simple way to link them is a shared timeline on the classroom wall. Each unit adds its source cards to the timeline, labeled with the claim they support. By the end, students can see how a migration route, a magazine and a public works project sit in one connected story, and which links in that story still need stronger evidence.
Bringing in ELA and the arts
The Harlem Renaissance lab pairs well with poetry. Poetry Performance Studio asks students to justify performance choices by connecting voice, timing and meaning, using short original poems. A combined block lets students study the networks that supported performance and then practice performance themselves.
For argument writing, the New Deal recommendation task works as a lead-in to Writing Effective Counterclaims, since students must acknowledge what their chosen project cannot do.
Moving to original sources
Both units are designed as practice before archive work. Once students can label links and limits on classroom cards, send them to original materials. The Harlem Renaissance unit already points to the Library of Congress collection, and the New Deal unit asks what a real local record would need to show to test whether a program served a neighborhood fairly.
A five-step sequence
-
Set the question
What networks supported the Harlem Renaissance? Which project best fits this town's needs?
-
Read the source cards
Students note what each card states and what it leaves unknown.
-
Build the diagram or comparison
Network map for the 1920s, project comparison table for the 1930s.
-
Test with a new source
Add an event program or a changed council priority and revise.
-
State a claim and a limit
Students write the strongest supported claim and one thing the sources cannot establish.
Common mix-ups and what to try
People in the same neighborhood must have known each other.
Closeness suggests a possible link. A program, letter or publication is needed to support it.
A public works project solves every local problem.
Each project fits some goals and not others. Students state what their chosen option cannot do.
One successful local example proves a national program worked.
A single case cannot show national results. Students list the evidence that would be needed.
More Social Studies units
Related teaching guides
Frequently asked questions
Do the units use original historical documents?
They use classroom source cards and modeled cases. The Harlem Renaissance unit points to the Library of Congress collection for original items.
Which unit fits Grade 7?
The Harlem Renaissance lab is written for Grades 7–10. The New Deal lab starts at Grade 8.
How long do both labs take?
Each is four 90-minute double lessons, about four weeks for both on a traditional schedule.
Can I teach these in an English class?
The Harlem Renaissance lab works well in ELA, especially paired with poetry performance. The New Deal lab fits US history or civics.
What if my social studies standards differ?
Every resource is built around the curriculum you teach – and if something doesn't fit your standards, the TeachLessons Guarantee applies: we adapt it for you.
Where are the other social studies units?
The social studies hub lists all eight history and geography units.
Ready for your next lesson?
Give out the magazine, club and map cards and ask students which connections they can actually prove.
View The Harlem Renaissance Source LabInstant digital download. Every resource is built around the curriculum you teach – and if something doesn't fit your standards, the TeachLessons Guarantee applies: we adapt it for you.

