Grades 9–12 · Career Readiness

How do you teach students to compare internship postings in Grades 9–12?

Short answer: Give students two or more fictional postings and a learner profile with real constraints, such as transit times and available materials. Students build a comparison table, mark which requirements fit, which do not and which are unclear, write one factual question for each employer, and make a conditional choice that names what would change it.

  • Grades9–12
  • Lessons4 double lessons, 90 minutes each
  • Includes42-page PDF, 16 slides, 5 worksheets with keys
  • Assessment20-point check, 100-point scoring sheet
Get Read and Compare Internship Postings – $24.99

High school students often read an internship posting the way they read an ad: they notice what sounds exciting and skip the details. Then the hours clash with their bus, or the posting asks for a writing sample they do not have, and the opportunity falls apart after they have already applied.

The Read and Compare Internship Postings unit teaches a more careful approach. Students read fictional postings against a learner's actual constraints, sort each requirement by whether it fits, and write questions where information is missing. The result is a conditional choice that a student can defend and adjust, along with the habit of asking employers factual questions before committing.

Units for this topic

Postings against a real profile

Posting A is paid summer tech support, 9 to 3, and requires reliable on-site travel. Posting B is paid remote documentation, 10 to 2, and requires a short writing sample. The learner has fixed transit after 4 and a sample draft.

Students build a comparison table and mark each requirement. B looks like a clear fit: the hours work, it is remote, and the learner has a draft. A depends on travel the learner may not have. The task asks for one factual question for each employer and a conditional choice.

Encourage students to read the learner profile before the postings, not after. When the constraints come first, students read each posting with a purpose and catch details like start times and travel requirements. When the postings come first, students tend to form a favorite and then look for reasons it might still work.

  • Hours: do they fit the learner's schedule?
  • Location: on-site, remote or mixed?
  • Requirements: samples, portfolios, orientation
  • Unknowns: what the posting does not say

When new information changes the choice

One task adds a detail: Posting A provides a ride that arrives by 8:45 and leaves at 3:15. Do both postings now fit? Students revisit the table and see that the travel problem may be solved, which opens up a real choice between the two.

The second context uses Posting C, in person from 8 to 12 with a portfolio required, and Posting D, remote from 10 to 2 with one in-person orientation. The learner cannot travel every day. Students compare. Then D changes to two recurring in-person days, and students state a conditional recommendation.

Writing factual questions

The transfer case gives a posting with a start time but no worksite. Students write one factual request for the missing information. The point is a question that gets a usable answer, such as asking for the worksite address, rather than a vague 'Can you tell me more?'

The learning check asks which piece of information would resolve uncertainty about the on-site commute. Students who can answer that clearly have learned the core skill: identifying what is unknown and asking about it directly.

Have pairs swap their questions and judge them with one test: could an employer answer this in a single sentence? If not, the question is probably too broad. Revising a vague question into a specific one is quick, and students can see the improvement right away.

Where the unit fits

The unit suits career readiness, CTE and work-based learning courses, and it works well a few weeks before students start applying for summer programs. It pairs with Compare Two First Job Offers, which compares offers under the same weekly time and travel assumptions, and with the Career Skills Evidence Portfolio, which prepares the evidence students will need once they apply.

The four double lessons move from the first postings to a model comparison, then a revised case and new context, then testing and transfer, and finally the learning check and feedback. All postings and profiles are fictional and contain no private identifiers.

A five-step sequence

  1. Read the learner profile

    List the learner's constraints: hours, transit, materials available.

  2. Build the table

    Put Posting A and B side by side and mark each requirement as fits, does not fit or unclear.

  3. Write employer questions

    Write one factual question per employer about something the posting leaves unclear.

  4. Make a conditional choice

    State which posting fits better and what information would change the choice.

  5. Update and check

    Add the ride detail for Posting A, revise the choice, then complete the learning check.

Common mix-ups and what to try

Instead of

The most interesting posting is the best choice.

Try

A posting only works if it fits the learner's hours, travel and materials. The table makes that visible.

Instead of

If the posting does not mention something, it is not important.

Try

Missing details, like the worksite, are often the ones that decide whether a posting works. Students ask about them.

Instead of

A recommendation should be final.

Try

The unit teaches conditional choices that name what would change them, such as a new ride or extra in-person days.

More Career Readiness units

Related teaching guides

Frequently asked questions

Are the internship postings real?

No. All postings and learner profiles are fictional. This keeps the focus on reading carefully and avoids any private information.

Which grades is it for?

Grades 9–12. It works especially well for students who will apply for summer programs, internships or first jobs in the coming months.

Can students use real postings later?

Yes. Once they know the routine, students can apply the comparison table and question step to real postings you approve.

How is it assessed?

Through five worksheets with answer keys and a 20-point independent learning check with model responses and a 100-point scoring sheet.

What if the unit needs to fit our work-based learning standards?

Every resource is built around the curriculum you teach – and if something doesn't fit your standards, the TeachLessons Guarantee applies: we adapt it for you.

What other career units are available?

The career readiness collection includes job offer comparisons, apprenticeship and college pathways, and workplace simulations.

Ready for your next lesson?

Put Posting A and Posting B side by side and ask students which one fits the learner before they say which one they like.

View Read and Compare Internship Postings

Instant digital download. Every resource is built around the curriculum you teach – and if something doesn't fit your standards, the TeachLessons Guarantee applies: we adapt it for you.