Grades 5–8 · PE

How do you teach students to design fair scoring for a PE target game in Grades 5–8?

Short answer: Have students record sample throws at each distance, calculate points per throw for each option, and compare. If one distance clearly pays better, they propose a scoring change and test it with a new sample. The goal is that near and far choices both stay worth taking, so players pick by challenge, not by math.

  • Grades5–8
  • Lessons4 double lessons of 90 minutes
  • Materials42-page PDF, 16 slides, 5 worksheets with keys
  • Assessment20-point check, 100-point scoring sheet
Get PE Target Games with Fair Scoring – $24.99

Offer students a near target worth 1 point and a far target worth 3, and you will see two strategies appear within minutes. Some players camp at the near line. Others throw from far because three sounds like more. Neither group usually checks whether its choice actually scores better.

The PE Target Games with Fair Scoring unit turns that moment into a lesson in fairness and simple data. Students record sample throws, compare points per throw, and adjust the scoring so both distances stay meaningful. It keeps students moving while giving them a reason to count carefully, and it fits well in a middle school PE program that wants students to think about game design as well as skill.

Units for this topic

The starting station

The station offers a near line with a 1-point target and a far line with a 3-point target. Four sample throws show 3 of 4 hits near and 1 of 4 far. Ask students which line is better before they calculate. Most pick one quickly.

Then compute points per throw. Near gives 3 points from 4 throws. Far gives 3 points from 4 throws. In this sample they are equal, which surprises students and opens the real question: will that balance hold with a different sample or a different group of players?

  • Record every attempt, hits and misses
  • Points per throw = total points ÷ attempts
  • Compare options using the same number of attempts where possible
  • Treat a small sample as a first estimate, not a final answer

When the balance breaks

Several cases change the numbers. In one, the near target scores 1 point and four of five attempts hit, while the far target scores 2 and two of five hit. Students compare sample yields. In another, far hits drop to one in five. Now the far line is clearly worse, and students suggest a way to rebalance it and a way to check whether the change worked.

A further task raises far hits to 2 of 4 with the same points. The sample now favors the far line strongly, and students discuss whether to lower its value or move the line. The learning check asks students to compute points per try for a 2-point target hit 3 times in 6 tries.

Recording fairly when methods differ

The transfer case adds a complication: players choose different ways to release the object, such as underhand, overhand or a seated release. Students decide what the record should include so the comparison stays fair. Usually that means noting the release method alongside the result, so the group can see whether a scoring change affects some players more than others.

This links to the unit's wider aim of offering suitable movement, performance and observation roles. Students who are not throwing can record attempts, which is real work in this unit, not a placeholder job.

Running it across four double lessons

Lesson one moves from first reading of the station to a model of points per throw. Lesson two revisits the scoring with a revised case and new context. Lesson three tests a proposed change and transfers the method to mixed release styles. Lesson four is the learning check and feedback.

If your class enjoys the data side, Food-Truck Service Time Data Project works with short datasets in math class, and PE Movement Assessment Stations uses observable evidence to set next practice goals.

A five-step sequence

  1. Set up two lines

    Mark a near line and a far line with targets labeled 1 and 3 points.

  2. Collect a sample

    Each group records four throws from each line, with a recorder logging hits and misses.

  3. Calculate points per throw

    Groups compute points per throw for both lines and compare.

  4. Propose a change

    If one line pays better, groups propose a new value or line distance.

  5. Test and check

    Run a new sample with the change, decide whether it helped, then complete the learning check.

Common mix-ups and what to try

Instead of

The target worth more points is always the better choice.

Try

What matters is points per throw. A 3-point target hit once in four throws gives the same as a 1-point target hit three times.

Instead of

Four throws prove the scoring is fair.

Try

A small sample is a first estimate. The unit asks students to test a change with a new sample before deciding.

Instead of

Fair means everyone uses the same throwing style.

Try

Players may release the object differently. The record notes the method so the group can check fairness across styles.

Related teaching guides

Frequently asked questions

Do students need a lot of equipment?

No. Two lines, two targets and objects to throw are enough. Many teachers use hoops, buckets or marked floor zones as targets.

Which grades does it fit?

Grades 5–8. Younger students can work with whole-number comparisons, while older students can handle points per throw as decimals and compare several samples.

Is this more math than PE?

It is PE with a data component. Students are moving for most of each lesson, and the calculations are short and tied directly to their own throws.

How does the unit include students who cannot throw from a standing position?

The transfer case covers different release methods, including seated options, and students record the method with each result. Recording and observation roles are also built in.

Can the unit be changed to fit our PE standards?

Every resource is built around the curriculum you teach – and if something doesn't fit your standards, the TeachLessons Guarantee applies: we adapt it for you.

Where can I find more PE units?

The PE collection includes movement assessment stations, cooperative challenges, an accessible movement circuit and a sports commentary lab.

Ready for your next lesson?

Set up the 1-point and 3-point lines next class and ask students to predict which pays better before they throw.

View PE Target Games with Fair Scoring

Instant digital download. Every resource is built around the curriculum you teach – and if something doesn't fit your standards, the TeachLessons Guarantee applies: we adapt it for you.