Grades 7–9 · Science
How do you teach using a decision key to identify a simulated unknown from measured properties in Grades 7–9?
Short answer: Give students reference cards with three properties, such as magnetism, solubility and density, and an unknown with measured values. They build a two-step elimination tree, follow it to the best match and identify which single test separates the closest candidates. When data fits no reference, they report the mismatch instead of forcing an answer.
- Grades7–9
- PropertiesMagnetism, solubility, density in g/cm³
- ToolTwo-step elimination tree (decision key)
- FormatEscape-style cases, 4 double lessons of 90 minutes
Properties of matter units often end with a table to memorize: density of aluminum, density of iron, which substances dissolve. Students can fill it in and still not know how to use it. Identifying an unknown turns that table into a tool, and a decision key gives the process a structure students can draw and check.
The Mystery Material Properties Escape Lab wraps that process in an escape-room format. Groups move to the next case only after solving the current one, and the final cases deliberately include data that does not fit neatly, so students practice honest reporting under a bit of time pressure.
Units for this topic
Mystery Material Properties Escape Lab
The lead unit: reference cards, elimination trees, escape-style cases and honest reporting of mismatched data.
Forensics Trace Evidence Stations
Trace evidence stations use a source matrix to narrow candidates, a close cousin of the decision key.
Fingerprint Evidence and Uncertainty Lab
The fingerprint lab adds an insufficient verdict for evidence that cannot support a comparison.
Ocean Acidification Investigation
Ocean acidification teaches students to spot threats to an inference in measured data.
Build a Library Search Algorithm
Build a Library Search Algorithm shows how step-by-step elimination works in computer science.
The starting references
Three reference cards describe the candidates. A is magnetic, insoluble and has a density of 7.8 g/cm³. B is nonmagnetic, insoluble and 2.7. C is nonmagnetic, soluble and 2.2. The unknown is nonmagnetic, insoluble and 2.7. Students build a tree: the magnet test removes A, and the solubility test separates B from C. The unknown matches B.
The worksheet then asks which single test separates B and C. Solubility does it in one step; density also differs, which leads to a useful discussion about which test is quicker or more reliable in a real lab.
Designing a good decision key
A decision key works best when each question splits the remaining candidates cleanly. Students compare trees that start with magnetism against trees that start with density. Both reach the answer, but one may need fewer steps or rely on a measurement that is harder to take precisely.
A second case gives an unknown that is magnetic, insoluble and 7.8 g/cm³, which leads straight to A. A follow-up removes the density value entirely and asks which further observation distinguishes B and C. Students realize that their tree still works if it uses solubility rather than density.
- Start with a yes or no test that removes at least one candidate
- Use a second test that separates the rest
- Record each measured value, not just the branch taken
- Check the final match against all three properties
When the data does not fit
One case gives an unknown that is nonmagnetic and soluble, but with a recorded density of 3.0. Two properties point to C, and the density does not. Students must decide how to report this. The strong answer names C as the closest match on two properties, flags the density mismatch and suggests re-measuring rather than claiming an identification.
The transfer challenge asks what makes a proposed third test useful when two reference solids share density and solubility. The answer, a test where the two references differ, is the core logic of every decision key. The learning check closes on a quick item: a sample is nonmagnetic and dissolves under the modeled test. Which reference remains?
Running it as an escape lab
Groups work through the cases in order, and each solved case gives them the next card. The four double lessons move from a first reading of the reference cards to a model tree, then a revised case and new context, then testing with the mismatched and missing-data cases and finally the learning check and feedback.
Keep a short debrief after each case. Ask one group to show its tree and another to show a different tree that reached the same answer. Seeing two valid keys side by side helps students understand that the structure is a choice, while the evidence at each branch is not.
Students who enjoy structured elimination often like Forensics Trace Evidence Stations, which applies a similar matrix approach to simulated traces.
A five-step sequence
-
Read the references
Groups list the three properties of each reference card in a small table before seeing the unknown.
-
Choose a first test
Students pick the test that removes the most candidates in one step and draw the first branch.
-
Finish the tree
Add a second branch that separates the remaining candidates. Follow it with the unknown's values.
-
Check all properties
Compare the match against every measured value, including the ones the tree did not use.
-
Report honestly
For the 3.0 density case, students write a report naming the closest match and the mismatch that needs re-checking.
Common mix-ups and what to try
If two properties match, the identification is certain.
An unknown that matches C on magnetism and solubility but has density 3.0 still has a conflict. Report it and re-measure.
Every test is equally useful at every step.
Once A is removed, magnetism tells you nothing more. Pick the next test where the remaining candidates differ.
Density alone identifies a material.
Two references can share a density. A key combines properties so that each step separates the remaining options.
More Science units
Related teaching guides
Frequently asked questions
Do students handle real materials?
No. All unknowns are simulated on cards, so the lab runs in any classroom without supplies or safety concerns.
What is the escape-room part?
Groups receive the next card only after solving the current one. It adds pace and a clear goal, but the reasoning on each card is the same structured elimination.
Is density calculation included?
The cases give measured densities. If your students are learning to calculate density from mass and volume, the extension cards are a good place to add that step.
How is it assessed?
Five worksheets with answer keys and a 20-point learning check with model responses and a 100-point scoring sheet.
Can the unit fit my physical science course?
Every resource is built around the curriculum you teach – and if something doesn't fit your standards, the TeachLessons Guarantee applies: we adapt it for you.
What do students produce?
Elimination trees for each case, a written identification with reasons and a report for the case where the data does not fit any reference.
Ready for your next lesson?
Lay out three reference cards and one unknown, ask for a two-step tree, and let Mystery Material Properties Escape Lab handle the rest.
View Mystery Material Properties Escape LabInstant digital download. Every resource is built around the curriculum you teach – and if something doesn't fit your standards, the TeachLessons Guarantee applies: we adapt it for you.

